Super teams have been the story of the NBA for the better
part of the past decade, with the Golden State Warriors' current collection of
All-Stars the greatest of them all. Is it possible to see such a thing in the
NHL? Given the current NHL landscape, probably not. The presence of a hard
salary cap limits what teams can do, and the very nature of the sport — the
best players only play a third of the game, and having two or three superstars
doesn't always guarantee success — makes it far more difficult to assemble that
sort of team. That doesn't mean NHL franchises have avoided trying.
Currently, the Toronto Maple Leafs and Tampa Bay Lightning seem to be engaged
in quite the arms race in the Atlantic Division with the former's addition of
John Tavares in free agency — adding to a team that already has Auston
Matthews, William Nylander, Mitch Marner and Patrick Marleau — and the quest of
the latter to add Erik Karlsson in a trade. If the Lightning can pull that off,
they'll add a two-time Norris Trophy winner who is perhaps the greatest
defenseman of this generation and one of the best ever to a team that already
has the reigning Norris Trophy winner (Victor Hedman), a Vezina Trophy finalist
goalie (Andrei Vasilevskiy) and a couple of MVP contenders (Nikita Kucherov,
Steven Stamkos) at forward.
Given the hard cap structure of the league, these are probably be the two best
examples — or at least closest examples — of "super teams" in the
NHL.
The pre-cap NHL was a different story entirely. Let's take a look back at some
teams that attempted to build monster rosters by assembling several All-Stars
and future Hall of Famers in one place, as well as the success and failures of
those teams.
Some of them succeeded. Some of them did not.
EARLY 1990S
PITTSBURGH PENGUINS
The Penguins had a lot of good fortune in the NHL Draft with
the opportunity to select Mario Lemieux in 1984 and Jaromir Jagr in 1990. Those
two became not only two of the best players ever, but the foundation for a team
that won back-to-back Stanley Cups and then a Presidents' Trophy from
1991-1993.
Management not only gave them help — they assembled a
stunning collection of talent through trades and free agency by acquiring six
different future Hall of Famers between 1988 and 1991. That list included Paul
Coffey, Ron Francis, Larry Murphy, Joe Mullen, Bryan Trottier and Mark Recchi,
whom the Pens drafted in 1988. That does not include starting goalie Tom
Barrasso, who probably has at least a solid argument to get in, and Rick
Tocchet, who scored 440 goals in his career. Add that group to the core of
Lemieux, Jagr and Kevin Stevens, and it is no wonder they were the premier team
of the early '90s.
They are one of only three teams to win back-to-back Stanley
Cups in the past 30 years, while their quest for a three-peat came to end in
1993 when they were upset by David Volek and the New York Islanders. That
Penguins team, which at one point won an NHL-record 17 consecutive games, was
probably the best of the bunch.
EARLY 2000S
DETROIT RED WINGS
By the early 2000s, the Red Wings were already back as an
NHL superpower. They won back-to-back Stanley Cups in 1997 and 1998, ending a
championship drought that had gone back to 1955; had homegrown superstars in
Steve Yzerman, Sergei Fedorov and Nicklas Lidstrom; and were led by the
greatest coach of all time behind the bench in Scotty Bowman.
For the 2001-02 season they assembled a monster.
Prior to that season, the Red Wings went all in on building
another Stanley Cup winner by signing Brett Hull and Luc Robitaille in free
agency and trading for Dominik Hasek to be their new starting goalie. This was
all done in one offseason — added to a team that already had Yzerman, Fedorov,
Lidstrom, not to mention previously acquired Hall of Famers Brendan Shanahan,
Chris Chelios, Igor Larionov and a young, budding superstar just getting his
feet wet in the NHL in Pavel Datsyuk.
They ended up winning the Presidents' Trophy by 15 points
(finishing with 116 points) while the only team to give them any sort of a
challenge in the playoffs was the Colorado Avalanche in the Western Conference
Final. The Avalanche, of course, were really the only team in the NHL at the
time that had anything close to the talent the Red Wings had.
2003-04 COLORADO
AVALANCHE
As mentioned above, the Avalanche were really the only team
in the NHL in the early 2000s that could compare to the Red Wings in terms of
talent. Their core was built around Joe Sakic, Peter Forsberg, Milan Hejduk,
Alex Tanguay, Ray Bourque and Rob Blake. Between 1996 and 2002, the Red Wings
and Avalanche combined to win five of the seven Stanley Cups. They were
powerhouses.
After seeing the Red Wings load up in 2002 with Hull,
Robitaille and Hasek, the Avalanche attempted to do the same in 2003 when they
added Teemu Selanne and Paul Kariya in free agency. The two were very clearly a
package deal given their prior history in Anaheim, while Kariya signed a
laughably small one-year contract far below his market value to join the Avalanche.
It did not produce the same result.
The Avalanche were really good but ultimately ended up
falling short of a championship after losing in the second round to the San
Jose Sharks. During the regular season, Selanne had one of the worst seasons of
his career, while Kariya was limited to just 51 games due to injury.
EARLY 2000S NEW
YORK RANGERS
We can put this one in the column of "super teams that
failed." During the 10-year run between the mid-1990s and the 2004 NHL
lockout, the league was a case of "the haves" and "the have
nots": teams that had money to burn and could sign anyone they wanted
(Detroit, Colorado, a handful of others) and the teams that, well, simply could
not compete with them.
The Rangers attempted to be one of the haves and between 2001
and 2004 acquired some of the biggest stars in the league.
Prior to the 2001-02 season, they traded for Eric Lindros,
the most dominant power forward in the league, after he missed the entire
season before due to a concussion and a contract dispute with the Philadelphia
Flyers. Later that same year they traded for Pavel Bure, the most dominant pure
goal scorer in the league. In 2003, they finally acquired Jaromir Jagr after
failing to get him in a trade a few years earlier and then reacquired Alexei Kovalev.
Do you know how many playoff games the Rangers played in
during those seasons? Zero.
Do you know how many winning seasons the Rangers had in
those seasons? Zero.
The problem the Rangers ran into was that even though they
acquired all of these All-Stars, they were not quite getting the best versions
of them. Lindros' career was beginning to spiral downhill due to concussions.
Bure's career was coming to a premature end due to knee injuries. Kovalev only
spent a season and a half with the Rangers before being traded.
The other problem: The rest of the team stunk.
The only one who saw any real success with the Rangers was
Jagr, rediscovering his dominant form in the Big Apple following the 2004-05
lockout and nearly winning a scoring title and MVP in 2005-06. After helping
lead the Rangers back to the playoffs between 2005-06 and 2007-08, he went to
Russia for three years.
2008-09 DETROIT RED WINGS
Maybe this is a bit of a stretch, but it is the closest
example we have in the salary cap era.
The Red Wings were coming off of a Stanley Cup-winning
season in 2007-08 with a team that was, to this day, perhaps the best team of
the salary cap era. They dominated. They made a Pittsburgh Penguins team that
had Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Marian Hossa and Sergei Gonchar look almost
helpless at times in the Stanley Cup Final.
They had the two best two-way forwards in the NHL in Pavel
Datsyuk and Henrik Zetterberg, a defense that was built around Nicklas Lidstrom
and Brian Rafalski, and just a really good, solid team around them.
Their response after winning the Stanley Cup: signing Hossa
away from the Penguins — the team they just crushed in the Stanley Cup Final —
on a one-year deal in free agency.
Given the success they had already had, it seemed to give
them an unbeatable roster on paper, and they had an amazing season with Hossa
leading the team with 40 goals in only 74 games. The Penguins ended up getting
the final laugh, though, in the Stanley Cup Final rematch, winning the series
in seven games, leaving us searching for the next "super team" of the
salary cap era.
No comments:
Post a Comment