WHAT ARE THE
STAKES FOR CHAMPION WEEK
Editor's note: The
NCAA tournament Bubble Watch has been updated through relevant games of Monday.
The unique March hybrid of tumult and high stakes known as
Champ Week is upon us, and Bubble Watch is so very here for all of it.
Here's a handy viewer's guide to the whole chaotic panoply.
...
Best conference tournaments for bubble drama
1. BIG EAST
Is this even up for discussion? You can't swing a cat at Madison Square Garden
without knocking over a teeming horde of bubble teams. Seton Hall is likely safe no matter what at this point
(along with of course Marquette and Villanova), but any other team not named
Butler, DePaul or Providence is trying desperately to either stay in the field (St.
John's) or play its way there (Creighton, Xavier and Georgetown).
2. ACC
How serendipitous! Clemson and NC State have been paired together in the
bracket in Charlotte, and the two will face off against each other Wednesday at
noon ET on ESPN. The loser of that game is looking at some serious bid peril.
A loss for the Tigers, for example, would drop Brad
Brownell's team to 1-10 in Quad 1 games. Is that really going to get it done?
Put another way, giving that profile a bid will (Bubble Watch can see it all
now) be seen as validating every categorical indictment in the book about
mediocre power-conference teams being coddled at the expense of feisty and
deserving mid-majors.
Meanwhile, the Wolfpack can't take anything for granted
either. Kevin Keatts' team also swung and missed on its best big-win
opportunities in conference play (0-7 in ACC Quad 1 games), though the victory
in Raleigh against Auburn is appreciating in value.
3. BIG TEN
How serendipitous (again)! Ohio State is plummeting down the same elevator
shaft where Indiana is ascending doggedly. The Buckeyes and the Hoosiers will
smack into each other Thursday afternoon in Chicago, and the loser may need
some capricious committee wackiness (seen with perhaps one bid a year) in order
to make the field of 68.
4. BIG 12
You can thank Texas for 100 percent of the bubble drama to be had in Kansas
City, Mo. The Longhorns, for some inscrutable reason, decided to play like a
bid was already in hand against TCU in the season finale, and now we have a
situation at the cut line.
If the Horns lose in the Big 12 tournament against Kansas,
they'll be 16-16. Is a 16-loss record really going to get it done for the first
time in NCAA at-large-bid history?
For their part, the Horned Frogs are back in this thing
after pulling off the upset in Austin. Jamie Dixon's team needs newer and
better wins, however, now that their "We swept Iowa State!" talking
point has lost some luster. TCU will begin that quest Wednesday evening against
Oklahoma State (7 p.m. ET, ESPNU).
Last thing. In addition to bubble drama, keep an eye on
those oh-so-sneaky bid thieves nationwide. Bubble Watch is looking at you,
Pac-12 and Atlantic 10 tournaments.
Here's how we're projecting the bubble right now. ...
BIDS FROM TRADITIONAL "ONE-BID" LEAGUES: 25
teams
LOCKS: 32 teams
THE BUBBLE: 27 teams for 11 available spots
SHOULD BE IN: 5 teams
WORK TO DO: 22 teams
ACC
LOCKS: Virginia, Duke, North Carolina, Louisville, Florida State, Virginia Tech
SHOULD BE IN: Syracuse
WORK TO DO: NC State, Clemson
SHOULD BE IN
SYRACUSE
ORANGE
Jim Boeheim's program has a history of close shaves on
Selection Sunday in recent years, but 2019 should be a somewhat more sedate
affair. Syracuse is now in the clubhouse, so to speak, at 19-12 and 10-8 in the
ACC. The Orange won at Duke, and the victory at home against Louisville also
qualifies as Quad 1. (The win at Ohio State, though fast depreciating in value,
will go in the books as a third Quad 1 victory.) If the selection were held
today, Boeheim's group would in all likelihood be looking at something in the
neighborhood of a No. 9 or 10 seed. That number can be revised upward,
naturally, with a good showing at the ACC tournament.
WORK TO DO
NC STATE
WOLFPACK
On paper, NC State should be fine. The Wolfpack finished the
season 21-10 and 9-9 in the ACC, and Kevin Keatts' team shows up in the mid-30s
in the NET rankings. So why are the mock brackets ticketing this group for, at
best, a No. 11 seed (and possibly even a 12)? First, NC State suffers from the
same malady that afflicted Auburn before the Tigers took down Tennessee at
home. The Wolfpack are accused of not having beaten "anyone," meaning
this group's 2-8 record in Quad 1 games features a win at home over (hey, what
do you know?) Auburn and another one on a neutral floor over Penn State. (To be
sure, the win over the Tigers looks better now than it did before the beginning
of March.) Second, NC State played a very soft nonconference schedule,
statistically speaking. Whether and to what extent the committee will care
about that second bit is an open question.
CLEMSON
TIGERS
The enemy for Clemson is now the rest of the bubble. After
winning at home 67-55 against Syracuse in the season finale, the Tigers will be
showing up on many "last four in" and, yes, "first four
out" lists. That's preferable to "next four out," certainly, but
it's still a precarious position to occupy heading into what is always a wild
and tumultuous Championship Week. Even the slightest contraction of the bubble
brought about by even a single bid thief, for example, could prove calamitous
to Clemson. Bottom line, there could be an at-large bid in the offing for the
Tigers even in the event of an early exit from the ACC tournament. A much more
appropriate working assumption for Brad Brownell and his men, however, would be
to approach the 15-team event in Charlotte as a classic "work to do"
situation.
BIG
12
LOCKS: Kansas, Texas Tech, Iowa State, Kansas State, Baylor
SHOULD BE IN: Oklahoma
WORK TO DO: Texas, TCU
SHOULD BE IN
OKLAHOMA
SOONERS
Shown as a No. 8 or 9 seed heading into a rather lopsided
68-53 loss at Kansas State, Lon Kruger's group has beaten Wofford at home,
taken care of Florida on a neutral floor and now stands at 4-10 in Quad 1
games. (For the record, the Sooners are 15-2 in Quads 2 and 3, and 0-0 against
Quad 4.) OU is going to the Big 12 tournament at 19-12 and 7-11, and across the
last couple of decades, those numbers have not been attached to too many
at-large teams. Nevertheless, there are plenty of teams below the Sooners on
the correct side of the 2019 mock cut line. The committee will determine the
real cut line, but barring a major surprise, Oklahoma appears to be on solid
ground.
WORK TO DO
TEXAS
LONGHORNS
This is what Bubble Watch is talking about with that whole
"40 minutes away" thing. With a win at home against TCU in the season
finale, Texas would be a world away from where the Longhorns find themselves
now. But where Shaka Smart's guys find themselves now is in the moral
equivalent of a must-win situation in the first game against Kansas at the Big
12 tournament. A loss there would leave Texas at 16-16 for the season.
Obviously, it would be unheard of for a .500 team with 16 losses to receive an
at-large bid, even if said team does have the neutral-floor win over North
Carolina and one at home over Purdue. "Unheard of" here doesn't
necessarily mean impossible, it just correctly flags the fact that we've never
seen it before. Reasonable observers can differ on the merits of the Horns'
profile, but, speaking empirically, asking the committee to do something it's
never done before is not a promising course of action.
TCU HORNED
FROGS
You have to tip your cap to the Horned Frogs. Going into the
game at Texas, this bunch from Fort Worth had possibly the least promising spot
in the history of teams on the "first four out" list. Now, after
winning 69-56 in Austin, Jamie Dixon's men are in position to lock down a bid
with a strong showing at the Big 12 tournament. The season sweep of Iowa State
that was looking like it would be a moot point can now be touted on the profile
of a team that captured a third Quad 1 win, convincingly, on the final day of
the regular season. TCU was given a chance, and the Horned Frogs took it. With
this single outcome, the bubble stakes for the Big 12 tournament, both for the
Horned Frogs and for the Longhorns, have been raised substantially
BIG
EAST
LOCKS: Marquette, Villanova
WORK TO DO: Seton Hall, St. John's, Creighton, Xavier, Georgetown
WORK TO DO
SETON HALL
PIRATES
Kevin Willard's team appears to have played its way into the
field of 68, and, if that is indeed the case, the really important basketball
with this team took place more or less exclusively in December and March.
Within the span of just 14 days in December, the Pirates beat Kentucky 84-83 in
overtime at Madison Square Garden and then won a 78-74 road game at Maryland.
Then things went quiet and even a bit dark for a bit, as SHU was 4-6 at one
point in Big East play. But, in the end, March smiled on the Hall, as Myles Powell and
his mates closed the season with back-to-back home wins over Marquette and
Villanova. Assuming a non-catastrophic performance by the Pirates at the Big
East tournament, Bubble Watch expects SHU to perhaps show up in the committee's
bracket as a No. 10 seed, give or take a line.
ST. JOHN'S
RED STORM
With St. John's, we're confronted with a classic case where
the danger might be understated by the numbers. If you were told that the
Johnnies were tapped as a likely No. 10 seed before they lost by 13 at Xavier,
you would probably conclude that the team will still be fine in terms of
getting an at-large bid. Bubble Watch isn't so sure. Chris Mullin's guys closed
the season by losing four of their last five games to finish at 20-11. The
Storm's NET ranking is in the 60s, and the signature one-point win at Marquette
has been dropping in value for the past two weeks. Strangest of all, perhaps,
is the underwhelming record against Quads 2 and 3 (7-6) from a team that has
held its own in Quad 1 games (5-5). Even though an at-large bid and a spot at
around the No. 11 line is still the most likely outcome, it does now appear
that this team's performance in the Big East tournament will have an impact on
its chances.
CREIGHTON
BLUEJAYS
For the balance of the Big East season, Greg McDermott's
team was a pincushion for the cruelest of the hoops gods, as the Bluejays lost
overtime games not only to Marquette but also to Villanova and Seton Hall. Then
in March, finally, Creighton started to even those accounts. Creighton got back
into this discussion by winning a close game on the road against the
aforementioned Golden Eagles, and the Bluejays followed that up with a
six-point victory at home, in overtime no less, over Providence. Lastly,
McDermott's men wrapped up the season with a 13-point win at home against
DePaul, meaning they're arriving at the Big East tournament at 18-13 overall
and 9-9 in-conference. The Bluejays have a shot.
XAVIER
MUSKETEERS
The Big East section of Bubble Watch is rather extensive,
but it's important to make distinctions even within the league's spacious
"work to do" section. Whereas a team like St. John's is looking like
it might play its way out of the bracket, Xavier has a long distance to travel
before it can even be glimpsed in "first four out" territory. Still,
the distance that remains to be traversed is nowhere near as vast as what the
Musketeers already have navigated over the past month. This is a team that was
11-13 and 3-8 in the Big East. Entering the conference tournament, conversely,
those numbers are 17-14 and 9-9. Travis Steele's guys put a capper on the
regular season by beating the aforementioned Johnnies 81-68 in Cincinnati
despite not having Naji Marshall(who
was out with an ankle injury). A trip to the Big East tournament semifinals
(which Xavier has reached every year since it joined the league) would keep
this conversation going.
GEORGETOWN
HOYAS
It's not going to be easy for the Hoyas. The win at
Marquette, naturally, kept this team in the discussion, and Georgetown will go
to work in the Big East tournament as the proud owner of four Quad 1 wins at
19-12 overall and 9-9 in conference play. That's all well and good, but the
profile also includes a couple of less pleasing aspects. The Hoyas are just 8-6
this season against Quads 2 and 3, and the team's NET ranking going into the
game in Milwaukee was a shield-your-eyes No. 80. So, no, it still won't be
easy, but Bubble Watch can envision a path to making this an interesting
question, a path that ends with beating either the Golden Eagles or Villanova
at Madison Square Garden. Keep going, Hoyas
BIG
TEN
LOCKS: Michigan State, Michigan, Purdue, Wisconsin, Maryland
SHOULD BE IN: Iowa
WORK TO DO: Minnesota, Ohio State, Indiana
SHOULD BE IN
IOWA HAWKEYES
After Joe Wieskamp hit
a spectacular game-winning 3-pointer at the buzzer on the road at Rutgers, the
Hawkeyes were 20-5 and mock brackets had Fran McCaffery's team pegged as a No.
6 seed. Since that time, however, McCaffery was slapped with a two-game
suspension (stemming from a tirade directed at referee Steve McJunkins after a
loss at Ohio State), Iowa has dropped to 21-10 and this team has seen its
projected seed plunge to the No. 9 line or worse. The Hawkeyes have relied on
offense all season long, but McCaffery's men have shot just 30 percent on their
3s while losing five of their past six games. Iowa will arrive at the Big Ten
tournament not merely looking to improve its seed but to rehabilitate it
WORK TO DO
MINNESOTA
GOLDEN GOPHERS
The regular season is in the books for the Golden Gophers,
and, in any normal year, you would say this is a team with great wins (at
Wisconsin and home against Purdue) and a so-so record (19-12 and 9-11 in the
Big Ten). Then again, bubble teams like Indiana are lapping the field in both
categories in 2019, so we must look elsewhere for superlatives specific to Minnesota.
Well, what about this: Richard Pitino's team has just about the tidiest 12-loss
profile you'll see anywhere. The Gophers are 9-0 against Quads 3 and 4, and
their "worst" losses come on the road to the major-conference likes
of Boston College, Rutgers and Illinois. Something dramatic in the way of a
disastrously fast exit from the Big Ten tournament or a severe bubble
contraction or both might have to intervene for Minnesota not to get the No. 10
or 11 seed that mock brackets are envisioning for this team.
OHIO STATE
BUCKEYES
With losses in their past three games and six of the past
eight, the Buckeyes have played themselves into jeopardy. The absence of Kaleb Wesson
for those last three games due to a suspension certainly didn't help matters.
Now, with OSU having dropped all the way to the No. 12 line in the mock brackets,
Wesson will return for the Big Ten tournament. That's where Ohio State will
face Indiana, and a loss for Chris Holtmann's men would leave them 18-14 after
an 8-12 run through the conference season. In theory, that could be good enough
to sneak this team into the field, given that the "18" includes the
win at Cincinnati on the first day of the season. Then again, a first-game
conference tournament loss for a team being shown as a No. 12 seed is never a
recommended strategy.
INDIANA
HOOSIERS
Indiana is 17-14 and 8-12 in the Big Ten with a season sweep
of Michigan State to its credit. The Hoosiers, of course, also have home wins
over Marquette and Louisville on their profile. As for IU's 6-9 record in Quad
1 games, perhaps the main point to be made there is that Indiana has played a
ton of Quad 1 games. What's less frequently cited, however, is the Hoosiers'
2-5 record in Quad 2 games. Will that data point play a significant role in the
committee's discussion? No one knows, and, anyway, this profile isn't finished
yet. IU is currently a "first four out" kind of team, but the Big Ten
tournament looms as a veritable Quad 1 outlet mall. If Indiana plays the
Spartans, Michigan, Purdue, Wisconsin, Maryland, Iowa or Penn State at the
United Center, it will be a Quad 1 opportunity.
PAC-12
LOCK: Washington
WORK TO DO: Arizona State
WORK TO DO
ARIZONA STATE
SUN DEVILS
Here's a Bubble Watch fun fact: Arizona State is the only
team in the "lock," "should be in" or "work to
do" categories that has lost games in all four quadrants. Yes, the losses
at home to Princeton and Washington State qualify as Quad 4 defeats, and,
indeed, the Sun Devils are a notably so-so 10-4 against Quads 3 and 4. See,
this is the kind of thing we miss with our single-minded focus on just one of
the quadrants. Now, let's focus single-mindedly on Quad 1: ASU's win in Tempe
against Kansas, as well as ones on a neutral floor against Mississippi State
and Utah State, might get this team a bid provided its NET ranking isn't too
controversially low. Going into Saturday's 72-64 win at Arizona, that ranking
was in the low 70s and Bobby Hurley's group was on Lunardi's "last four
byes" list. It could work out as is, but if the Sun Devils want to feel
safe there's work to do.
SEC
LOCKS: Tennessee, Kentucky, LSU, Mississippi
State, Auburn
SHOULD BE IN: Ole Miss
WORK TO DO: Florida, Alabama
SHOULD BE IN
OLE MISS
REBELS
The Rebels faltered down the stretch and lost four of their
past six, but things could be worse in Oxford. Ole Miss uncorked a late 7-0 run
to win the season finale at Missouri, and, anyway, this is a team that does own
road wins at Auburn and Mississippi State. Not to mention this program was picked
in the preseason to finish last in the SEC and has made just two NCAA
tournament appearances in the past 17 years. When those are the givens and you
falter your way into a No. 9 or 10 seed with your new coach in his first
season, the future looks pretty encouraging.
WORK TO DO
FLORIDA
GATORS
In what is fast becoming a recurring Bubble Watch theme,
let's discuss a major-conference team with a bad record compiled in numerous
Quad 1 games. Florida is 3-11 in Quad 1 contests, with the wins all coming on
the road at LSU, Alabama and Arkansas. (Fun fact: UF was singularly
unsuccessful at home against the best teams this season.) It is primarily the
win against the Tigers, naturally, that has lifted the 17-14 Gators up to the
No. 11 line in mock brackets. Speaking of single games that had a significant
impact: Florida's late-season loss at home to Georgia (part of an 0-3 finish to
the regular season) has left this team in a position in which a quick exit from
the SEC tournament would expose Mike White's guys to a high degree of bracket
peril
ALABAMA
CRIMSON TIDE
Alabama closed its regular season with an 82-70 loss at
Arkansas, a game in which the Crimson Tide allowed Daniel
Gafford to record a 29-16 double-double. The loss leaves Avery
Johnson's team at 17-14 and 8-10 in the SEC -- in other words, classic bubble
material. Speaking of peak bubble, Alabama entered the game in Fayetteville as
a member in good standing of Lunardi's "last four in" list. The Tide
landed in this degree of peril despite having a home win over Kentucky on their
profile, and, naturally, the SEC tournament will offer a wide array of quality
opponents and plenty of chances to impress the committee. The larger concern
with Alabama, however, is that this team hasn't won a game against an NCAA
tournament-caliber opponent since January.
AMERICAN
LOCKS: Houston, Cincinnati, UCF
WORK TO DO: Temple
WORK TO DO
Temple Owls
UCF's late-season ascendance was good news for Temple. The
Owls beat the Knights 67-62 in Philadelphia in the season finale, and it was
very much a Quad 1 win. Paired with the home victory against Houston, Fran
Dunphy's team now has a couple of real profile boosters to flaunt as it fights
for a bid. Right, about that fight: Temple entered the game against UCF perched
right on the boundary line between "in" and "out."
Obviously, beating the Knights pushes you in the correct direction, but a
single game can't push you all the way to safety. So it's good news for Owl
fans that their team now has a chance to put even more distance between itself
and jeopardy thanks to an American tournament populated by the Quad 1-opponent
likes of UH, Cincinnati, UCF and Memphis
OTHERS
LOCKS: Gonzaga, Nevada, Buffalo, Wofford, Murray State
SHOULD BE IN: VCU
WORK TO DO: Utah State, Belmont, Saint Mary's, UNC Greensboro,
Furman, Lipscomb
SHOULD BE IN
VCU RAMS
Mike Rhoades' men are riding a 12-game win streak thanks
primarily to outstanding defense. Now, at 25-6 overall and carrying an outright
Atlantic 10 regular-season title, VCU has a No. 8 or 9 seed waiting for it in a
matter of days if mock brackets are to be trusted. There are no remaining Quad
1 opportunities for the Rams even in any potential A-10 tournament game, but
the 54-53 win at Texas in December will continue to fill that need on the
profile quite satisfactorily.
WORK TO DO
UTAH STATE
AGGIES
Utah State came really, really close to furnishing us with a
very interesting conversation. After everyone had declared the coronation
complete with the win at home against Nevada, the Aggies went on the road and
needed overtime before escaping with a 100-96 win at Colorado State. Now Craig
Smith's team is indeed assured of at least a share of the regular-season Mountain
West title. Projected as a No. 11 seed, USU really has only two remaining
dangers. One is a shrinking bubble, and the other would be an ostentatiously
early exit from the conference tournament in Las Vegas. But, assuming both of
those disasters fail to materialize, Utah State does appear to be in good shape
for its first bid since 2011.
BELMONT
BRUINS
Now, the Bruins must wait. Ja Morant erupted
for 36 points, and Murray State beat Belmont 77-65 in the Ohio Valley
Conference title game. Rick Byrd's team hopes the committee will put stock in
the positives on this profile. There is, for starters, the NET ranking that, at
least when Belmont stopped playing, was higher than those of Iowa, Ohio State,
Indiana, TCU, Temple, Minnesota, Alabama, Arizona State and the entire Big East
bubble (Creighton, St. John's, Xavier and Georgetown). The Bruins also were
short-handed against the Racers and played without Nick
Muszynski. Lastly, Belmont was 5-3 this season against Quads 1 and
2. Conversely, Byrd's men won't want the committee to linger on a negative like
the 3-2 record against Quad 3. In any event, the Bruins profile is set, but the
bubble will continue to shift in ways that will either help or hurt Belmont's
chances.
SAINT MARY'S
GAELS
Oh, what might have been. No, Bubble Watch doesn't mean the
69-55 loss to Gonzaga in Moraga, California. The Bulldogs are looking more and
more like a team of destiny, and Mark Few's guys running the table in the West
Coast Conference was never going to be a huge upset. Instead, think about the
four-point losses Saint Mary's recorded against Mississippi State and LSU in
November and December, respectively. Either one of those games moved under the
win column would make this a much stronger profile for the Gaels. As it is,
however, the single Quad 1 win coming on the road at New Mexico State might not
be sufficient to get SMC into the field of 68. That said Saint Mary's stays in
Bubble Watch due to its beautiful NET ranking and a collective and incorrigible
ignorance in the world outside the committee room concerning what exactly that
will mean in Year 1 of the new metric's reign.
UNC
GREENSBORO SPARTANS
For 35 minutes in the Southern Conference title game, the
Spartans were the superior team against Wofford. Then the Terriers closed the
contest on a 20-3 run, and Mike Young's team captured the automatic bid 70-58.
As for at-large possibilities, UNCG actually shares some profile similarities
with Wofford. Like the Terriers, Wes Miller's team has an excellent record
(28-6) built on a small number of "good" losses to LSU, Kentucky,
Furman and, yes, Wofford (three times). The Spartans own two Quad 1 wins (at
East Tennessee State and over Furman on the neutral floor in the SoCon
semifinals), and Francis Alonso & Co. are an immaculate 24-0 in Quads 2, 3
and 4. Could all of the above plus the impressive showing against the Terrier
juggernaut (21-0 against SoCon opponents this season) pry an at-large bid from
the committee? In Bubble Watch's estimation, it's a long shot.
FURMAN
PALADINS
The season is in the books for the Paladins after a 66-62
loss to UNC Greensboro in the Southern Conference tournament semifinals. Bob
Richey's team sits at 25-7 with the memorable win at Villanova to its credit. Alas,
that win (plus a sweet NET ranking in the 40s) might form the sum total of the
case for Furman on Selection Sunday. It's not a bad case, but the Dins may have
trouble standing out from the crowd. Saint Mary's, to take one example, has a
NET ranking that's even sweeter than Furman's.
LIPSCOMB
BISONS
The Bisons show two Quad 1 wins on their profile, at TCU and
at Liberty, and their NET ranking is in the 40s. Those are the elements that
kept Casey Alexander's group in the at-large discussion for weeks, but Lipscomb
let its safest chance slip away when it lost 74-68 on its home floor to Liberty
in the Atlantic Sun conference title game. An at-large now appears to be a long
shot.
No comments:
Post a Comment